1688 - Edward Lloyd ran a coffee shop in which merchants met with wealthy people to arrange insurance
1730s - Lloyd' begins to dominate shipping insurance
1734 - Lloyd's list appears
1750 - Underwriting first appears
1764 - Weak and leaky vessels
1768 - Lloyd's, the notorious gambling den
1769 - New Lloyd's appears
1773 - John Julius Angerstein developed the concept of the lead underwriter
1787 - First metal hulled boat (a barge) was built in Shropshire
1803-1815 - Napoleonic Wars
1775-1815 - American revolution and establishment of the Patriotic Fund
1799 - Loss of the Lutine
1817 - Invention of the Bicycle
1818 - First Steamship to cross the Atlantic (the Savannah)
1824 - Liberation of insurance industry so that more independent companies could write insurance.
1833 - Abolition of slavery in the UK
1851 - Financial security was made more rigorous
1858 - The Lutine Bell was salvaged
1863 - Invention of the Internal Combustion Engine
1865 - Abolition of slavery in the USA
1870 - Frederick Marten invented the concept of large syndicates
1871 - First Lloyd's act
1877 - Non-marine policies were introduced into Lloyd's
1880 - Cuthbert Heath wrote the first reinsurance policy
1890s - Lloyd's established itself in America with a new brand of entrepreneurial brokers
1905 - Risk based pricing
1902 - The Burnard failure, and the introduction of auditing
1903 - Wright Brother's first flight
1903 - Delegated authority introduced and Lloyd's was able to write insurance all around the World
1906 - San Francisco Earthquake and invention of Excess of Loss insurance
1908 - Audits become compulsory
1911- The Lloyd's Act
1912 - Titanic sank (loss of £1m)
1914-1918 Many Lloyd's staff fought in WWI and Lloyd's also made many contributions to war related charities
1923 - Harrison's folly and the creation of the central fund
1928 - Lloyd's moved into 12 Leadenhall Street
1930 - 3rd party insurance for driving vehicles on a road become compulsory
1939 - LLoyd's was effectively moved to Pinewood studios and staffed by 500 women to continue operations during world war II
1965 - Salto Grande and Itaipo Dams in South America
1973 - First female broker
1977 - The Council of Lloyd's was established
1983 - wearing of seat belts in the front seat became compulsory in the UK
1985 - Lloyd's started insuring nuclear power stations in China
1988 - Lloyd's Tercentenary Research Foundation set up
1980's and 1990's - Scandal Fraud and huge losses (Piper Alpha, Asbestos claims etc.)
1990 - The losses were worsened by the LMX spiral.
1992 - Hurricane Andrew (177,000 made homeless)
1993 - David Rowland appointed and this led to the setting up of Equitas to manage the related liabilities at a cost of £21bn
1993 - Bishopsgate bombing and establishment of Pool Re
1994 - Corporate members introduced (capacity £1,595m)
1998 - FSA introduced to regulate Lloyd's
2001 - September 11
2002 - Annual reporting introduced
2003 - Creation of realistic Disaster Scenarios
2005 - Hurricane Katrina - over 100 killed and tens of thousands left homeless
2007 - Contract certainty ended the markets 'deal now, detail later'
2010 - Deepwater Horizon
2012 - Vision 2025 launched
2020 - COVID 19 losses and first ever closure of Lloyd's building
More information can be found on many of these events on the Lloyd's website
First we need to consider how policies written, accidents happening, being reported and claims being paid out are used to fill values into the various different run off triangles that we can use.
Once we have data in a triangle the mathematics of calculating the reserve is the same whatever the triangle represents
First we need to consider a timeline
A policy is sold (written in 2012)
The premium is then earned continuously over the next 12 months
An accident happens in 2013 during the term of the policy
In 2015 this accident is reported to the insurance company and the benefit is believed to be £450
In 2016 this claim is settled for £600
So where do these numbers go in the different triangles
First we consider IBNR by accident year
The bold line represent the current time at year end 2016
As the accident happened in 2013 and was reported in 2015 we can see this represents development year 3 for accident year 2013
What if we do an underwriting year triangle. Then we wish to consider when policies were written in respect of which accidents happen
This policy was written in 2012 so it is reported in development year 4
What about reported but not settled - this time we group accidents by the year in which they were reported
So this accident goes in reported year 2015 and is settled in development year 2
What about the paid triangle - this considers when claims were actually paid out
If this is grouped by accident year then this claim was paid in 2016 which is development year 4 for accident year 2013
But we can also do a paid triangle by underwriting year
This time the policy was written in 2012 for which the claim is finally paid out in 2016 that is year 5
Often quoted as prices of consumer goods
Readily available in many markets
Often not the most appropriate for insurance though
Tends to be higher than price inflation
Will be a major part of many claims due to repair and rebuild costs
Also a major part of insurance company admin costs
There is a tendency for liability and compensation payments to far exceed the rate of inflation as judges award bigger and bigger compensation payments
In the USA compensation can be awarded by a jury as well
No win no fee law firms can also cause an increase in the propensity of firms to want to make a claim
Prices for labour can be squeezed higher just when there are most claims for a multiple claim event due to supply and demand of labour
Medical expenses tend to have their own higher rate of inflation and a specialist index should be used if possible
It's more than just weather and climate
You have just started a new job as an actuary in a growing insurance company which has been in business for 3 years and writes mainly personal lines household insurance policies, which are sold through a nationwide network of a major high street bank.
The CEO is ambitious to grow the company and wishes you to give your opinion how he might go about this:
i)List four different ways the company might grow its business
[2 marks]
ii)For each of these options discuss how such an expansion policy could cause risk to the business
[8 marks]
iii)Discuss the ways in which a reinsurance company may be able to help your company manage and mitigate the risks identified
[4 marks]
[Total 14 marks]
i) different business lines such as motor, holiday and pet
different sales channels such as price comparison websites
increase sales commission to high street banks (no longer legal in UK)
reducing prices
increasing cover options
advertising
ii) relevant points such as:
lack of experience
lack of data to parameterise models
pricing at a loss making level
increasing concentration of risk
adverse selection
moral hazard
each point should be explained in the context of the different business strategy it causes a risk to.
Negative cashflows at acquisition of policy
iii)
for each strategy sensible reasons from
cover for large losses (illustrate why this more likely)
cover for concentration of risks
availability of data and experience
smoothing of profits
financial structures to absorb initial negative cashflows
The President of the South American Insurance Oversight Board has written you a letter in which he informs you that the Board is considering introducing continent wide insurance legislation for the whole continent of South America.
i) State the advantages and disadvantages of this suggestion
[4 marks]
ii) Outline, with justifications, the main features that you would expect such a piece of legislation to contain
[6 marks]
Total 10 marks
(i) ensures less developed countries catch up with better reserving standards
protects policyholders
reduces systematic risk to economy of insurers collapsing
enables greater ease of M&A transaction in the insurance world
increases confidence in insurance which could increase take up and so improve people's cover generally
Could be very expensive for individual countries and companies to implement
Might be worse than original standard
Could be so complicated that it actually increases risk due to inability to enforce
May be implemented in different ways in different countries
May cause complacency and replace more qualitative risk management standards
(ii) Outline could be a high level Solvency II structure or a Lloyd's market structure: may include following structures:
process for calculation of best estimate reserves
process for calc of risk margin on which to base market value of liabilities
process for calculation of at least one capital requirement
procedure for regulator and company action when capital requirements are breached
procedure for internal management of risk
procedure for reporting of compliance to regulator
Moodle Course Reading - 04. Introduction to Non-life Insurance